Rape is Rape: How the Culture of Shaming, Stigma, and Victim-Blaming is Hurting Us
by Rachel Halder on Dec 18, 2012 • 9:30 am 16 CommentsYesterday I became overwhelmed by the news. First of all, the stories from Newtown, Connecticut are enough to make anyone’s stomach churn. Then my pain doubled when I opened a New York Times piece on a small town rape incident.
A teenage girl, only 16-years-old, was black-out drunk at a party. Drug around naked and raped by two football players, the events were watched by others and recorded on cameras, then plastered all over the Internet. Yet, many in the town blame the girl for making the football team look bad, and those who posted the pictures online didn’t see anything wrong in their actions. They weren’t even disciplined.
This isn’t the first time I’ve read something this appalling. In 2011, The New York Times reported on a gang rape of an 11-year-old girl. Within their article it was insinuated that she was to blame for what happened to her, stating “she dressed older than her age, wearing makeup and fashions more appropriate to a woman in her 20s.” Locals were reported asking, “How could their young men have been drawn into such an act?” As if an 11-year-old lured them in with her sexual powers and convinced them to rape her in a brutal and violent way.
I was equally upset these past few weeks by articles The Good Men Project published. The first piece, by Alyssa Royse, told the tale of her friend who was rightly accused of rape. The jaw-dropping title of her piece was “Nice Guys Commit Rape Too.” On Feministe Jill Filipovic described it as “the worst thing I have read about rape all year.” Then to top it off, the next week The Good Men Project published an equally horrifying piece titled, “I’d Rather Risk Rape Than Quit Partying.” The writer also stated that he’s “pretty sure I’m technically a rapist,” and that “In the real world, especially among experienced drinkers, being blackout drunk … can look like being very sexually aggressive.” He concludes with, “I’ve accepted a certain amount of rape as the cost of doing business.”
Before I was even entrenched in my women’s studies minor and theoretically understood the full effects of rape culture and victim-blaming, I instinctively knew about this cultural phenomenon. At a Christmas party, a previous friend of mine was constantly hitting on me. I rejected his advances, though attempted to do so in a non-rude way. I told him that no, I did not want to sleep in the same bed as him, and I kindly reminded him of the fact that he had a girlfriend.
When I woke up that night with him on top of me I hurriedly removed myself from the situation and went into a different room with multiple people in it, even though the room I previously slept in also had more people than just he and I. Later when I woke up to him again, this time with his hands down my pants, I shoved him away and left the apartment—at 3 AM—and walked a mile and a half back to my car where I sat alone for an hour until I felt safe enough to navigate my way through the foggy roads back home. Though I knew it wasn’t my fault I still found myself running through a list of all the things I would be accused for doing wrong: I had been drinking, I didn’t protest enough, I didn’t scream at him, maybe I hadn’t been direct enough in my “NO” (though I knew that my actions would have told almost anyone else that no really meant no).
I wrote him an email the next day explicitly telling him that what he had done was extremely wrong, that I was appalled and angry at his actions, and that he had to know and understand his misdoing. I even went into explaining rape culture, though I didn’t know it was labeled that at the time, and focused on how women are to blame in most situations like this. I said that I’m a strong woman; a woman less sure of herself may not have left the room before something worse had happened. Thankfully he responded in repentance and told supportive friends and family about the event in hopes to gain some guidance.
Even so, the next time I saw him two years later I had such an extreme anxiety attack that I hid from his view.

Though this may seem a stretch, we must think of rape crimes in the same light as other crimes. We don’t accuse those who have things stolen from them for flaunting their wealth in front of others. The majority of murder victims knew their attacker, yet no one calls it “acquaintance murder.” Why is rape different? (image via http://seesuzysketch.blogspot.com/2011/01/victim-blaming-cartoon-for-safer.html)
Both in the United States and around the world we blame rape on the woman. Women such as me understand this message at a young age. Guilt, shame, and stigma are ingrained into the center of our being. We slut-shame women ourselves, saying “What was she wearing last night?” or “She’s so flirtatious, it’s her own fault!” This exists in our Mennonite and church communities, too. That guy who stuck his hands down my pants while I was sleeping was a good Christian Mennonite, who went to both a Mennonite high school and college, and who was and still is well-liked by many.
Almost every piece of news that accompanies a situation of rape focuses on a woman’s appearance, her behavior, whether or not she was participating in drinking or drugs, and her sexual history—not a single one of those facts is mentioned about the perpetrator. If anything, it’s a message of disbelief: “But he was such a stand-up guy! I can’t believe he would have done something like this. There must be a mistake.”
Last Thursday I hosted a Twitter conversation about victim-blaming for Women Under Siege, the organization I work for. Hosting the conversation with UK Laura Bates’ project Everyday Sexism, our goal was to promote conversation about victim-blaming and the cultural roots of stigma in situations of sexualized violence and rape around the globe; stories we’re collecting on our Web site. Using the hashtag #RapeisRape allowed tweeps to contribute their own thoughts, stories, and solutions to the conversation of victim-blaming.
(Side Note: If you are Twitter illiterate like my parents, yet you want to have a bit of an idea what I’m talking about, check out this wiki on hashtags and this on twitter chats for a better grasp on the world of tweeting.)
As the social media associate I prepared for the chat by helping create a hashtag, writing questions, compiling stories, preparing links to publish, and contacting writers and journalists who would be interested in joining the conversation. What I didn’t prepare for was the emotional toll of hearing, talking, and reporting on the stigmatizing affects rape have on women worldwide.
During our conversation over 1,500 tweets were generated, which made 3,351,589 impressions (or in other words, that many people saw at least 1 tweet with the hashtag #RapeisRape), and Women Under Siege reached an audience of 1,067,521 followers through 1.5 hours of conversation about legitimate rape. Five days later, people are still using the hashtag #RapeisRape.
What I took away from the conversation was that there is an extreme need for women to have an outlet to voice their stories and frustration with rape culture and stigma. One tweet (@MMASammich) said, “I was 12 when I was raped, and completely unprepared for the accusations from all sides.” Another tweep (@stupid_fairy_) stated, “Makes me sick to hear the rape jokes around my school. It’s not funny. Imagine if it happened to you all; how would you feel?”
Stories are powerful. When voices come together to report the shame each individual experienced from their rape, change can occur. Through this twitter conversation solutions were thought up, a few of which included:
@nixenji “We must encourage responsible media reporting and avoid victim blaming in articles like this”: http://t.co/rBA0Mkj8 #RapeIsRape
@Fem2pt0: “Instead of teaching female students how 2 avoid getting raped, we should be teaching men how 2 avoid being rapists” J. Friedman #RapeIsRape
@MMASammich: We must call #victimblaming out wherever we see it. We must teach boys about rape. We must insist that #RapeIsRape.
@SACLondon: Let’s start healthy relationship corners by teaching our kids about consent and respect #rapeisrape
@kaptinkaiju: We need media outlets to “outshout” the victim blamers #RapeIsRape
In order to live a spiritual life we must be aware of victim-shaming. I had a friend in college who was victim-shamed by the administration because she too had been drinking when she was raped. Our churches have events where victim-shaming occurred, like when we say “But he was such a nice guy!” instead of listening to a woman’s full story. We’ve said detrimental statements about women (and men) who “deserve” what happened to them, such as that girl in your high school class who always let her cleavage show.
Let’s focus our attention towards story-telling, compassion and love rather than the why of each event. Let’s gather together in a community of reconciliation and restorative justice. Let’s focus on helping the abused live through their pain, which is the most important aspect our communities should be paying attention to. Let’s not participate in rape culture and shaming, a culture that is detrimental to all of us, especially our inner-most spiritual being.
For more on victim-blaming, check out this great piece: Eight reasons why victim-blaming needs to stop: Writers, activists, and survivors speak out


16 comments
Clarice Faber says:
Dec 20, 2012
Rachael, a powerful piece…thank you for telling the story, and for the work you are doing…not easy, but such a work of value.
Rachel Halder says:
Dec 20, 2012
Thank you, Clarice! I appreciate (and need) the positive feedback.
elizabeth says:
Jun 10, 2013
Thank you for sharing. I had thought that since I was sexually assaulted back in the late ’60′s that the fear of being blamed was more of my generation. Furthermore,If there was no penetration we cannot even call it rape.
I was driven down a dark road,no city lights, no houses…no hope of any help. And this was my first boyfriend.
I have lived with Psychological Dread and Trauma for most of these 40 years.
I was a Minister’s Daughter. I even heard a comment a few years ago from a retired police officer:”Oh Minister’s Daughters,they’re the worst!”no True. I did NOT agree to go down that Dark Road. Never did,never will.
I have been the target of shaming,slander..re-victimized in the small city where I live. This Blaming of the Victim has got to stop! The problem is that as long as the victim is to blame then these kind of men believe,wrongfully, in their “Entitlement to sex with anyone they lust after”.These kind of men do not See or consider a woman as a Human Being with Rights and Feelings and Needs of her own.To these kind of men, they see women as Objects rather than as living and breathing human beings with the right to be respected.
I have lived with these Attitudes of Prejudice for most of my life. I have felt so alone. It is hard for me to have a consistently close trust relationship with Jesus since He is ALL powerful and therefore, I believe that He could Stop these sexual assaults.Where is the God of love when so many women and children and boys are sexually abused. Many of these victims are further victimized by being told that they are now deemed to be mentally ill.When in fact they just cannot face their self blaming and shame and dreaded fearfulness. The “victims’ of sexual abuse Need Courage and encouragement to face their fears and feelings of helplessness and get back their strength and determination to live a full and strong life. We must encourage the Victims to talk and to be heard.
If I live for nothing else I hope I can speak out and become an Advocate for those Survivors of sexual abuse.Theo Fleury is speaking out in Canada for those who have survived sexual abuse.
Unfortunately even “helpers” so often want the victim to consider themselves as mentally ill.The lack of understanding and support is trial enough. To not be believed in is nearly unbearable. I couldn’t concentrate to my usually high level of achievement since I couldn’t talk for nearly 38 years about what happened.
Then the Church told me: Just forgive and everything will be all right. When I said I had forgiven,I was told that I hadn’t really forgiven from my heart. It’s not so much about forgiving the Perpetrator but rather about getting one’s power restored so that one can live with accomplishments and fearless dignity and self respect,etc.
I had other men who were of the same mentality.Their implicit Demand that I give them sex..since I owed it to them and they were “entitled”.
A woman is Not an Object. I am not an Object. When a young person is sexually abused,their power to state their boundaries,to say No and to be respected for having rights is STOLEN from them. Since it is often true that the victim is still developing their Identity they then come to the wrong conclusion that I must be an Object.No. Wrong conclusion.
You are Never an Object .You are Never someone’s else’s possession.
No man has the right to use you.
My sexual assault happened by the first man that I had dated. He lied to me for about 2 months,telling me repeatedly that I could trust him.
How could I know that he was “grooming” me to terrorize me with the Dark Road. I said Take me Home and he acted like a “mad man” and didn’t respond.Instead of saying that there was something wrong with me we ought to question the Sanity of the men who commit these ACTS of TERRORISM. They must be made to attend Mandatory Counselling for at least 5 years. We must turn the tables.
Stop blaming the women.It goes back to blaming Eve for the trouble. We as women are NOT the guilty ones.
WE are EQUALS in the Eyes of Jesus.Any man who wants a sex object ought to get himself a Plastic Doll.I mean it.
I personally have suffered for over 40 years. I am tired of being the victim of Soul Theft.
I want my Soul restored to me. I want the Me that I was created to be to be restored completely and I want the Perpetrator to realize that he had No Right to drive me there nor to take the Beauty of sexuality and make it something ugly. When he forced me to do his bidding when I was in a state of shock and great fear, I lost the DREAM of sexual Beauty and Romantic love. I tried for years to get it back.Finally in my 30′s I married and by then I couldn’t trust anymore. So very sad.
I am sick and tired of being blamed.
Rapists Must take responsibility for the Crime that they have committed. A woman is Not an Object. Some men treat their own sex the same way. It has got to stop.
One other thing.I had a “boyfriend”(come to think of it,boy-friend isn’t really true.He was NOT a friend). He was a similar kind of man.Demanding sex when he had no real commitment to me.He pressured me in his lust and self centered way. He used me in other words. I finally got rid of him after several attempts.
He never knew how to appreciate another person’s boundaries. Now several years later he has had the nerve to move in just right next door to where I live. I have lived here for 15 years. He has no respect for the boundaries of myself. It is hard to find Peace when a man is so invasive…but I keep seeking for “my sanctuary”.Thanks for reading,Elizabeth
Rachel Halder says:
Jun 10, 2013
Thank you for sharing your story. You seem very brave in your telling, and even though you’ve faced a lot of opposition, you’re still able to name the truth about what happened to you.
Is there any chance you want to share this to Our Stories Untold “Stories” page? If you would like to, you can submit it here: http://www.ourstoriesuntold.com/stories/ Please request if you want it anonymous and if the story can be edited for correct spelling, grammar, and so it reads better overall.
Thank you again for your bravery.
Majka says:
Dec 20, 2012
Thank you. Thank you for writing this, for working with it and for the campaign.
Ilene Flannery Wells says:
Dec 20, 2012
34 years ago, I woke up to a man walking towards me with a gun in his hand, and he dropped his pants and told me to be quiet. He had climbed in my second story window of the 4-bedroom house my sister and I had rented with two other college friends, who were out of town. unbeknownst to me, my sister was out of the house with friends…I was a long…it was 3am…
I was lucky – i actually beat off my attacker. It is a long story…
But the point that is relevant to this article is that when my boss heard about it, he lectured me about leaving my window open and a ladder in the yard, which my attacker had used to gain access.
Rachel Halder says:
Dec 20, 2012
Ilene, thank you for sharing this story. How traumatizing! I’m so glad to hear you fought off your attacker and other then the emotional affects of what had happened, you were otherwise untouched. And how completely inappropriate and appalling of your male boss! And unfortunately, what a common response. This is what I’m hoping to combat with this post. Thank you again for sharing.
Ilene Flannery Wells says:
Dec 20, 2012
I wrote few pieces about how rape survivors are used as pawns of the abortion debate…I actually had a bad case of flashbacks from the amount of times I heard the “r” word over the past two years.
It got exponentially worse once Akin made his idiotic comments. That moment was blessing in disguise for women’s rights but the firestorm that erupted made that word ring in my ear so much i coudn’t stand it so I wrote on Reader Supported News about it.
Here’s one…Feel free to use what I wrote any way you want…
http://www.tinyurl.com/pawnsofGOP
Ilene Flannery Wells says:
Dec 20, 2012
Stories are the only way to get these points across. Since you mentioned the Newtown shootings… I do mental health advocacy work…my twin brother Paul had schizophrenia…had a terrible life…and I am trying to use his story to facilitate change in the system…you can read about him and the changes I think are needed on my website (click my name).
I wrote all of it long before Friday, by the way, but everything I say in there would help people with serious mental illness…and that alone could help prevent some of these tragedies from even happening…
Sabrina L. says:
Dec 30, 2012
“The majority of murder victims knew their attacker, yet no one calls it “acquaintance murder.””
True, but they do pretty much the same thing, minimizing the culpability of the murderer by placing blame on the victim. I mean, of course: the victim is usually guilty of being a woman. The acquaintance murders (aka intimate femicide) are definitely considered of less significance, perhaps since she is thought (unconsciously?) to be his property to do with as he pleases. We call these incidents domestic disputes that get out of hand instead of male violence that culminates in murder.
http://hsx.sagepub.com/content/early/2008/11/13/1088767908326679.abstract
http://marybyronproject.wordpress.com/2012/06/11/disputing-dispute-troubling-patterns-in-domestic-violence-rhetoric/
http://www.whataboutourdaughters.com/waod/2012/12/3/the-crucifixion-of-kasandra-perkinsvictim-blaming-black-mate.html
http://mediamisses.wordpress.com/2012/12/04/nice-guy-kills-girlfriend/
Rachel Halder says:
Dec 30, 2012
I agree with you completely. I wasn’t trying to downplay victim-blaming in murder and partner or domestic violence scenarios in making that remark. Perhaps it was carelessly stated. I just wanted to make the point that rape victims are often blamed unfairly, as are all victims of violence, whether that violence is physical, emotional, racial, class related, or so on. Thank you for posting the articles. They provided further important insight.
Purity, lust and religion: How the church allows rape to thrive | Our Stories Untold says:
Jan 8, 2013
[...] December I posted the above cartoon and asked “Why is rape different?” One-third of women [...]
Purity, lust and religion: How Christianity confuses rape with sex | Council for World Mission says:
Jan 22, 2013
[...] In December I posted the above cartoon and asked “Why is rape different?” One-third of women murdered in the United States are killed by intimate partners, but we don’t call it “acquaintance murder.” Why must we then label rape committed by a partner or friend as acquaintance rape? I quickly answered my own question after getting frustrated with the language a woman used in a blog. The content of her piece was good. Focused on forgiving the man who raped her twin sister, I really couldn’t argue with her compassion or enlightened understanding in the situation. But I did feel the language used was detrimental to the cause. [...]
Rape: Do you care? | Our Stories Untold says:
Jan 31, 2013
[...] and has manifested itself across the globe–the U.S. is not excluded. Rape prevails as a stigmatized blame game in which victims are continually disregarded and shamed in our communities. Rapists are defended, [...]
Thoughts on Steubenville: Calling for collective writing submissions | Our Stories Untold says:
Mar 19, 2013
[...] the Steubenville situation since a New York Times article came out in December, which provoked this piece on victim-blaming, I still haven’t been able to sift through my emotions and feelings enough to actually articulate [...]
Global Scope and Magnitude of Violence Against Women | Religion's Cell says:
Mar 23, 2013
[...] Rape is Rape: How the Culture of Shaming, Stigma, and Victim-blaming is Hurting us [...]